Grudge vs. Forgiveness

August 6, 2001

Question

Dear Dr. Love,

I hope that you will take the time to read my story and provide me with feedback. I really don't know what to do. I am a 36 year old single mother. I have a loving relationship with Gary, the father of my 2 year old son, Justin. We have been intimately involved for four years. When I first initiated a relationship with Gary, I was living with a man named Mitchell and Gary was involved with a woman named Cheryl. It was understood that we were each already involved in serious relationships, so we agreed to have an open, nonexclusive relationship.

Later, I changed my mind and decided that I wanted a sexually exclusive relationship with Gary, and started fighting with him about it. After I had a child, our conflict over monogamy intensified. To make it worse, Gary was very ambivalent about being a father. To his credit, Gary has always been attentive, loving, even doting, towards our son. But it did freak him out to suddenly have a child out of wedlock.

After some couple's counseling, we chose to take a self-development class together about sexuality and relationships, which was sponsored by our church. At that time, Gary gave up his relationship with Cheryl and focused his energies on his relationship with me. One year later, our relationship is better than ever. We have much less conflict, monogamy is no longer an issue, and Gary is becoming a better father.

Although we aren't married and still maintain separate households, Gary and I have a very close relationship. We spend almost every night together and take most of our meals at Gary's house (He cooks!) We take all our vacations together as a family. We make love twice a day and Gary is dedicated to satisfying me completely. I feel more love in my life than I ever have had. Gary lavishes affection on me and would do anything for me. He likes to surprise me with jewelry and flowers. He is the most nurturing and devoted man I have ever been involved with. Our friends marvel at how good we are together. Gary is passionately in love with me and wants to marry me.

My dilemma is that I still feel anger and resentment towards Gary for refusing to agree to monogamy with me for so long. And I am angry that he didn't at first, want me to have his baby. I am so angry that I am considering leaving Gary. What should I do? Am I nurturing an unfair and unhealthy grudge, or am I justifiably pissed off? Should I try to forgive Gary and make a life with him, or should I leave him?  Thanks.


Answer

It's not my role to tell you to either forgive or to nurse a grudge. It is my role to help you understand why you find yourself in the predicament of being unable to let go of the grudge. With this understanding, you should feel freer to move forward and make your own unconflicted choice. The first thing you need to understand is that whenever we hold on to a feeling, in this case the feeling of resentment, and 'can't' let go, that feeling is being fueled by an unresolved childhood wound.

Perhaps an example will help you see what I mean. Let's say I am at a store and a salesperson looks down her nose at me and talks to me like I'm stupid. Let's say that my father used to do the same thing to me. A person without my history, would shrug off the incident, thinking what a jerk the salesperson is. By contrast, the person with my history will experience a disproportionately strong emotional reaction, a reaction that doesn't quit. I will be enraged, maybe for more than a day. Unless I can make the conscious link between my past and the current reality and say to myself, 'Oh yeah, the salesperson reminds me of my father,' I will find it hard to shake my feelings.

The tricky thing is that most times our minds link present events with past wounds without our knowing it. All we are aware of are the feelings, which actually block our minds from thinking clearly and making the links that we need to make. What you need to understand is that the reason why you can't shake the grudge is because your boyfriend's refusal to immediately come around and be your exclusive partner has awakened a childhood wound of yours. To figure of what wound you are nursing, you must link past and present. To do this, ask yourself, 'How does my current grudge echo my childhood wounds? Who forced me to fight and beg for attention or love and seemed to never come through?'

I would imagine that you felt wounded by a parent who neglected you. The result is that you are living with a lot of buried hurt and anger. This buried anger is linked to why your mind doesn't want to drop the grudge. To figure out what your mind hopes to gain by hanging on to the grudge ask yourself, 'What's my pay off for holding on to a grudge?' Realize that no pattern exists unless it meets a need, albeit an unconscious need.

So, you have to figure that feeling so resentful serves you on some level. Here's one likely pay off: your grudge gives you an excuse to release your anger. You aren't alone. People who have been wounded or victimized in childhood often feel the need to rage at their mates. It's as if they are releasing all the pent up rage toward their parents, and paying them back symbolically, by raging at their mates. The thing that you can't forgive your boyfriend for (not coming around sooner) is surely something that you resented your parents for. You may be using your boyfriend to get even with your parent.

The sad fact is that we never succeed in draining our emotional barrels using this operation. No amount of raging at a boyfriend will ever make up for what you were cheated out of as a kid. Meanwhile, the raging ruins your life and relationship in the present. You will also want to study if there are additional pay offs for hanging on to the grudge. I have to wonder if you are unconsciously using this grudge as a "Secret Warfare" Fight Trap, a distancing tool (ending the relationship because of your grudge--as you are contemplating doing--is the ultimate distancing act). I am quite sure that you are conflicted about becoming too close to a any man. Notice that you chose to dilute your primary relationship by becoming involved with Gary who, himself, was attached to another person. Then you later decided that you wanted Gary exclusively.

But did you really? You finally got him and now all you can think about is leaving him. I have the impression that the struggle to make an unavailable man yours is far more compelling for you than simply enjoying the love that is being offered to you now without a fight or struggle. You need to see how this relates to your history. Again, people who have been deprived in childhood tend to choose lovers who will continue depriving them. Partly because it's familiar and partly to try to resolve the original wound with a parent.

Well, you resolved the struggle with Gary, you got him to be responsive, but, as you can see, your original wound is still not healed. You are still feeling resentful and living in the past. Drowning in past resentments prevents you from enjoying your ride in the present. I have given you a great deal of insight into the root cause of your grudge. Now, it's time to enter therapy and separate past from present. Gary sounds like a peach. If you don't work-through and resolve your childhood baggage, your grudge will devour you and the relationship, preventing you from enjoying the fruit of your love.

- Doctor Love


Did you find this article helpful, informative, inspiring?

If so, please help me keep this site alive and growing by spreading the word to others or checking out my books and programs. You can:

Get Your Ex Back With Dr. Love's Relationship Rescue Kit Syncrohearts Board Game