Dear Dr. Love,
I hope that you will take the time to read my story and provide me with feedback. I really don't know what to do. I am a 36 year old single mother. I have a loving relationship with Gary, the father of my 2 year old son, Justin. We have been intimately involved for four years. When I first initiated a relationship with Gary, I was living with a man named Mitchell and Gary was involved with a woman named Cheryl. It was understood that we were each already involved in serious relationships, so we agreed to have an open, nonexclusive relationship.
Later, I changed my mind and decided that I wanted a sexually exclusive relationship with Gary, and started fighting with him about it. After I had a child, our conflict over monogamy intensified. To make it worse, Gary was very ambivalent about being a father. To his credit, Gary has always been attentive, loving, even doting, towards our son. But it did freak him out to suddenly have a child out of wedlock.
After some couple's counseling, we chose to take a self-development class together about sexuality and relationships, which was sponsored by our church. At that time, Gary gave up his relationship with Cheryl and focused his energies on his relationship with me. One year later, our relationship is better than ever. We have much less conflict, monogamy is no longer an issue, and Gary is becoming a better father.
Although we aren't married and still maintain separate households, Gary and I have a very close relationship. We spend almost every night together and take most of our meals at Gary's house (He cooks!) We take all our vacations together as a family. We make love twice a day and Gary is dedicated to satisfying me completely. I feel more love in my life than I ever have had. Gary lavishes affection on me and would do anything for me. He likes to surprise me with jewelry and flowers. He is the most nurturing and devoted man I have ever been involved with. Our friends marvel at how good we are together. Gary is passionately in love with me and wants to marry me.
My dilemma is that I still feel anger and resentment towards Gary for refusing to agree to monogamy with me for so long. And I am angry that he didn't at first, want me to have his baby. I am so angry that I am considering leaving Gary. What should I do? Am I nurturing an unfair and unhealthy grudge, or am I justifiably pissed off? Should I try to forgive Gary and make a life with him, or should I leave him? Thanks.




