How Do I Show Him That Our Relationship is Worth Rekindling?

October 29, 2001

Question

Dear Dr. Love,

My boyfriend of 2 1/2 years broke up with me about a month ago. I am having a horrible time dealing with this because I never saw it coming. I mean, I knew we had our problems but I never dreamed he was that unhappy. He didn't say anything to let me know until it was too late he thought our relationship was irreparable. When I look back on it, I see the signs that were there. I don't know if I chose to ignore them or if I really didn't notice. I think I was probably in denial of a lot of things.

When we first started dating, we had sex all the time. I was very aggressive in that department. But, the longer our relationship went on & the further into my emotional self I allowed my boyfriend, the sex became less & less. It was like I was afraid to let him in on all the levels of my personality. I was afraid he would end up wanting me just for sex. It's ridiculous to admit. . . he's so much better of a person than that. I guess it stems from years of being that girl who couldn't separate sex from love.

I'm 27 now, he's 29. I should be over things that happened 8 or 9 years ago, and I'm getting there, but I'm not completely. I feel so insecure sexually I don't know what to do. He said, somewhere near the end of our relationship, that he was willing to help me overcome my sexual shyness. So, my problem right now is this. . . I know where my shortcomings were in the relationship. . . I was not as forthcoming emotionally or sexually as I should have been; I didn't put forth all of the effort I should have.

He was unwilling to talk about his unhappiness because he didn't want to bother me with it. He's always been that way, but he's getting better. Anyway, he's dating someone now who was there for him emotionally when I was not and now I want him back. I've told him I still love him and he said he loves me too, but I don't think he means he's'in love' with me. I've told him all the things I should've said when I realized there were problems and now I'm just waiting for him to talk.

He's out of town for a quarterly business meeting right now and said he'd talk to me about all of this when he gets back, that he was blown away by all I had to say and was pretty much speechless at that time. Granted, I have sent so many mixed signals the past few weeks, I understand how he's so confused. How do I show him that our relationship is worth rekindling. . . that it can be repaired. He is the only person I've ever loved like this.

I've dated other men that I never saw a future with, but he's the one I can close my eyes and still see when we're old and grey. I know that this can work, how do I convince him? I know this has been a long, long letter. . . thanks for your patience and hopefully for your advice.


Answer

I totally understand your predicament. The only way that you can hope to rekindle the relationship is by opening your heart and telling him everything that you told me. In addition to what you said in your letter, you are going to need to address a few more points. You are going to need to reassure him that you fully understand and are working on resolving the mechanism that led you to withdraw from him sexually. You said to me that you withdrew from him sexually and that you stopped making sexual advances because you were afraid that he would only want you for sex.

In a nutshell, you were in the grips of an unconscious defense mechanism. The purpose of a defense mechanism is to protect the self from danger. For example, if a woman is afraid of being rejected, she might withdraw (that 's the defense) from contact in order to protect or defend herself from the pain of the rejection that she fears will occur. Her withdrawal, paradoxically, makes her boyfriend think that she doesn't care and he rejects her. As this hypothetical scenario shows, the defense mechanism that she employed actually made her worst fear come true: she was rejected in the end.

You need to become expert at understanding the defense mechanism(s) you use. You need to identify each one and then figure out what feeling or outcome you are trying to protect yourself from; next, you need to develop the skill of watching yourself (using what's called the observing ego) so that you can catch yourself before you employ your habitual defenses. This is your only hope of saving this relationship (if you get back together) and of saving yourself from one failed relationship after another (in the event that you don't get back together). When talking to your ex. , he needs to see that you are on top of the problem, that you are aware of your defenses, and that you are working on dissolving them using the observing ego process.

In order to feel safe to try again with you, he needs to know that you are working to resolve the problem. Next, we need to clue him in on a thing or two regarding himself. He needs to see that he employs a defense mechanism that is going to ruin every relationship he is in. What is his defense? He backs away or avoids a direct discussion of what is bothering him. He didn't tell you what was wrong; he let his feelings fester until it was too late. He needs to figure out what his defense is protecting him from? Does he avoid telling what's bothering him in order to avoid a confrontation? He needs to see that his avoidance brings about even more than the confrontation that he's trying to avoid--it brings about the end of the affair. Now he's starting over with someone new.

Make no mistake. He will find himself in the same mess with her as he did with you. No partner is perfect, and she will surely disappoint him in various ways. He won't speak, will harbor resentment, that resentment will fester and build, and one day he will walk out on her. The point being, if he loves you as much as you love him, he might as well work this pattern out with you rather than transport his problem to the next relationship. My argument is most compelling.

Now we need to hope that he didn't allow his resentment toward you to erode his love for you. If the love is gone, we won't be able to bring him back to you. If, however, his love for you is as strong as yours is, we have a good chance of bringing him back using the above approach. Please let me know what happens. I am rooting for you both.

- Doctor Love


Did you find this article helpful, informative, inspiring?

If so, please help me keep this site alive and growing by spreading the word to others or checking out my books and programs. You can:

Syncrohearts Board Game