Why Would He Tell Such an Eerie Lie

December 10, 2001

Question

I have been married for 9 years. This is my second marriage, I have 2 children from the previous marriage, now ages 21 and 23. My husband and I have no children together.

Before we were married, my husband told me that he had fathered a child with a girlfriend. He said the child had died at 5 months of age from a fall. He has told me about this baby boy throughout our marriage, and i have in turn shared this information with my family - at times when they asked about our desire to have a child. He has told me of special times he had with the child and shared with me his sadness over the child's death.

Now, 9 years later, when i pressed for information about where the child was buried, and when his birthday was and what day he died, in order to possibly share in his feelings about this, he told me it never happened, that there was not a child, that he had made it all up. He cannot give me a reason as to why he would tell such a lie, and I am having a hard time believing anything he says.

After all the terrible details he shared, about finding the child at the bottom of the stairs with a fractured skull, etc. . . - I feel very creepy when I even look at him. We went to counseling at our church but he was incapable of opening up, agreed with everything I said and didn't share his heart.

So, i gave up the counseling, and he did too. things are pretty terrible here right now and I need some advice. . . can you tell me what you think about why someone would tell such an eerie lie? HELP!!!


Answer

Children live in the world of make believe. They create stories and fantasies that help them come to terms with all kinds of emotional struggles. It sounds like your husband has a childlike personality. I suspect that when he couldn't bear a certain feeling, he created a make believe story, just the way children do, in order to help him cope.

He needs to be helped to face his feelings and talk them through, rather than discharge them in childish fantasies. You might start by telling him that when a person makes up a story it's because he is trying to soften unbearable feelings inside himself and/or satisfy an unmet need.

You could give him the following example. A child who is abandoned by his father creates an elaborate fantasy life in which he pretends that his father is sailing the high seas and will return to visit him as soon as he can free himself from the pirates who are holding him captive. This story softens the unbearable pain over the father 's absence and offers the child hope that his wish to see his father again will one day be fulfilled.

After explaining the reason why one makes up stories, ask him if he can think what need he's been trying to satisfy and/or what feelings he's been trying to ease via the phantom son story. Ask him if he's frustrated that he never had a son. Does he suffer over the fact that you both weren't able to have a son? Did he create a make believe child to soften the pain over never having had a son and or to satisfy--at least in fantasy--the wish to have a son?

If this is so, then this make believe story was the only way he could think of to deal with his pain. Once he told himself, and you. the story he was forced to expand upon the story with another fabrication--that the child died. He had to say the child was dead since he was unable to provide evidence of a real life child!

I hope that I have given you insight into why the story was created. Your husband is more emotionally fragile than you may have realized. His storytelling was the only way that he could think to deal with feelings that he felt too fragile to face. The fact that he couldn't speak to the priest is further evidence of his inability to face certain feelings. He must sense that his psyche would crack if he had to face his feelings head on. Understanding this about him should help you to see him in a new light.

He is damaged and fragile and needs to be handled with kid gloves. Let me know how your talk goes.

- Doctor Love


Did you find this article helpful, informative, inspiring?

If so, please help me keep this site alive and growing by spreading the word to others or checking out my books and programs. You can:

Get Your Ex Back With Dr. Love's Relationship Rescue Kit Syncrohearts Board Game